Home
Classifieds
Contests
Subscribe
Work with us
Mostly Cloudy,80°
Monday, July 6, 2015
Contentious Island Park chamber election
Chamber elects Ingoglia, Scully
Howard Schwach/Herald
Mark Tannenbaum, of the Long Beach chamber, at the meeting.

Glenn Ingoglia was re-elected president of the Island Park Chamber of Commerce and Michael Scully was elected vice president at a contentious, often angry meeting at the South Shore Jewish Center on Dec. 12.

Ingoglia received 20 votes, while his challenger, Frank Naudus Jr., received nine. Scully garnered 19 votes for vice president, while challenger Joe Pontecorvo received 4. There were 29 voters out of 38 eligible voters — paid members of the organization.

That term —“paid-up” members — became an important one, as many of those in the audience who claimed to be members of the chamber were refused the right to vote in the election.

Glenn Bacigalupo, the vice president of the Island Park Library, was one of those who was not allowed to vote, despite the fact, he said, that the library has been a chamber member for more than five years.

“Ingoglia showed up for photos when the library reopened after Sandy,” Bacigalupo said. “He used us as a photo op to further his own agenda. We are listed as a member on the chamber’s website. He never told us that we are not members. I don’t understand this at all.”

Larry Chorne, the owner of Island Advantage Realty, was another participant who walked out of the meeting angry because he could not vote. “We worked with the chamber after Sandy, and we donated 500 trees to the community through the organization,” Chorne said. “So I come to this meeting to vote, and I’m told that I’m no longer a paid-up member and can’t vote.”

As Ingoglia called the role of those who were allowed to vote, many business members who were passed over in the alphabetical call grew angry and challenged Ingoglia, who stood his ground at the podium and refused to take questions. “We are conducting an election, and that is all we are going to do tonight,” was his answer to every question.

Bonnie Leibstein, the owner of Jewelry by Steven, told the Herald that she had given Ingoglia a check for her membership dues, but it was never cashed. “Why didn’t he deposit my check and then tell me I’m not a member?” she asked. “I believe it’s because he did not want me to vote tonight. This is terrible.”

Comments

4 comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment
BizMomOf2

Island Park Chamber of Commerce is a disgrace!

Wednesday, December 18, 2013 | Report this
netwrk219

What's disgraceful is that this "news" entity seems unable to report the news without taking a side or showing a bias. I will not judge the chamber based on the comments made by those quoted here.

The members of the chamber will have to provide their explanation, which they seemingly have. To judge based on this rag of a newspaper is not advised.

Wednesday, December 18, 2013 | Report this
navycpo

Who is being held accountable for the factcheck in this trash newspaper. Names wrong, story misrepresented, about the only fact correct was the date. The author should apologize to the people of Island Park, for the contentious lies contained here. I will be calling and cancelling my subscription after nearly 18 years. I can no longer willingly support this kind of one sided garbage. This story will do more to divide an already shattered community. Shame on all of you

Thursday, December 19, 2013 | Report this
mtann12

MARK TANNENBAUM

December 22, 2013

On Thursday, December 12th I attended my second Island Park Chamber of Commerce meeting. I was in attendance for two reasons. One, I wanted to get an explanation from the chamber membership as to why I was blackballed from being a member considering I have a professional business practice in Island Park (Harbor Isle). The second was that I received an invitation from over 25 Island Park businesses to attend the meeting to see how Glenn Ingoglia, the President of the chamber runs the meeting and the chamber.

It was pretty shocking to see how Mr. Ingoglia acts as a dictator not permitting anyone but himself or maybe his cohorts to speak and refusing to answer any questions. The membership clearly has no say in what happens both during meetings or in this chamber. Mr. Ingoglia, President of the Island Park Voice Party, a political organization, clearly demonstrated that the Island Park Chamber is his own personal political organization and the businesses of Island Park have no say. Being an Executive Vice President of the Long Beach Chamber of Commerce and running their meetings I know how a meeting should be run and I found this meeting to be a disgrace to chambers everywhere.

In attendance at this meeting was Howard Schwach, a reporter for the local paper, the Herald. Mr. Schwach wrote an article describing what he saw take place at the meeting. Business after business being told they could not vote or were not a member. Mr. Ingoglia wrote a letter on December 18th rebutting the article and dismissing and denying what took place. If anything, Mr. Schwach’s article was rather soft when he described how the meeting was handled and what took place. In fact, I would say that Mr. Ingoglia’s response letter was quite incongruent with the facts as he sought to justify his own inappropriate handling of the meeting and the elections for the Chamber’s officers.

The article could have elaborated further how member after member was denied membership and not permitted to vote. But interesting enough Michael Posillico, whose rental development was turned down unanimously by the Town of Hempstead Council, was permitted to vote. In fact just last week Mr. Posillico was seen with Mr. Ingoglia and Michael Scully reapplying for the same project that was all ready turned down. I still wonder why an outsider like Mr. Posillico was given the privilege to vote in the chamber election while legitimate businesses in the community were not permitted to vote. It would seem proper that the President of the Chamber be working to have Mr. Posillico immediately clean up that environmental dump that he has owned some 14 years, instead of trying to help him get rental units built that won’t pay school taxes in the community for 20 to 30 years.

As for Mr. Ingoglia’s comments and Mr. Schwach’s portrayal of me they are distorted and incomplete. First of all, this issue is not about me but rather about Mr. Ingoglia, the President of the Voice Party and his handling of the Island Park Chamber as his own political club. He talks about the Herald making this political but it is rather Mr. Ingoglia as President of the Voice Party that makes it political.

As for me, for some reason Mr. Schwach constantly focuses on my being Executive Vice President of the Long Beach Chamber. My leadership role in the Long Beach Chamber does not have anything to do with this matter. I am involved in this matter because I am one of the Island Park businesses and also a resident who is unhappy with the politics in the Island Park Chamber and I believe the business community should have a real Chamber of Commerce not a political organization. As for some (3 individual’s) of Mr. Ingoglia’s supporters in the crowd chanting, “Go back to Long Beach, you’re a disgrace,” and “Leave, leave”, that is true, but an incomplete portion of the story. When I picked up my coat and said “I will leave”, the majority of the crowd chanted for me to stay. Had I not been wanted I would definitely have gone.

Mr. Ingoglia’s actions are deplorable. Whoever heard of a chamber not accepting members? Mr. Ingoglia refused almost 30 members from joining the chamber during the month of November and December. But he did permit his Voice Party, a political organization, to join. Then to justify his refusal of membership, he amended the By-laws: keeping those businesses from joining or paying their dues. Mr. Ingoglia made up his own rules by making an amendment, change, resolution, however he wants to term it, and not taking it to the membership to vote on. The only way By-laws can be changed is by a vote of the membership.

A group of 25 plus businesses organized in order to elect a new slate of officers that would represent the interests of the business community, not the Voice Party and Mr. Ingoglia’s run for Mayor. That slate would have won by a large margin that night if all the businesses present were permitted to vote.

Even though the opposing slate lost the election the business community won because Glenn Ingoglia has been exposed for the tyrant he is. He demonstrated that only what he says and does counts. The business community of Island Park has no say or representation in the Chamber. Only now that he is ‘safely’ in control of the Chamber, is he looking for businesses to join it. In hindsight, I realize that I am glad that they did not except my membership as I would be embarrassed to be a member of such an organization.

It is time for the business community to take action. To join the Chamber and give it your money and support while Glenn Ingoglia and Michael Scully do what they want endorses what they have been doing. It is time to start your own organization, one that represents ALL of the businesses AND the community.

Sunday, December 22, 2013 | Report this
Terms of Use | Advertising | Careers | Contact Us | Community Links © 2015 Richner Communications, Inc.