On and Off Broadway

'Not the Messiah (He’s A Naughty Boy)'

Reviewed by Elyse Trevers

Posted

Those already tired of traditional holiday music will find a delightful change of pace in Eric Idle and John Du Prez's "Not the Messiah (He’s A Naughty Boy)" at Carnegie Hall. Based upon Monty Python’s movie The Life of Brian, the story follows young Brian Cohen, born in a manger right near Jesus. He gets involved in politics and later, despite his protestations, attracts hordes of followers who call him the Messiah. They urge him to tell them what to do.

The cast is led by Idle himself and features Broadway performers Victoria Clark (Cinderella, Light in the Piazza) and Marc Kudisch, Lauren Worsham (Gentleman’s Guide to Love and Murder) and opera singer William Ferguson. The cast is backed up by the 180-voice Collegiate Chorale. In addition there is a full orchestra, the Orchestra of St. Luke’s, and the NY Metro Pipe Band. There’s something for everyone.

The story and music are satirical, and songs like “Hail to the Shoe” mock religious orthodoxy as the followers seek meaning in Brian’s lost sandal. Much of the humor comes from the contrast between the lush operatic music and melodies with the silly lyrics like “smelly” and “stupid.” The music is a mix of styles ranging from pop, country, hip hop, Greek and folk. Wearing sunglasses, Idle comes out strumming a guitar and playing a harmonica a la Bob Dylan. When the masses proclaim Brian as the Messiah, there’s a lavish show-stopping number complete with candles and bagpipes.

There is only one familiar song “Always Look on the Bright Side of Life” (from Spamalot), yet it is easy to sing along and almost impossible not to move to the music. Although the oratorio has been presented throughout the world, including Australia and New Zealand, the Carnegie Hall performances mark the New York premiere. Sadly the production has a very limited run, but mark it down to see next year. The holiday season is always a good time to look at the bright side of life.