Wantagh and South Side entered Sunday night’s Nassau Conference III football semifinal matchup at Hofstra University with identical 8-1 records, and plenty of history between them.
The programs have combined for three county titles in the past three years, and Wantagh kept its dream alive for a third straight with a 21-7 victory following a scoreless first half.
The third-seeded Warriors avenged a 21-14 loss to the Cyclones in the regular-season finale on Halloween and advanced to face No. 1 Plainedge in the championship game Saturday at 4 p.m. at Hofstra.
“That's just a good game between two good teams,” Wantagh head coach Keith Sachs said. “The first half was even. In the second half I was just very happy to see us play good football both on offense and defense.”
The first half was a defensive battle, with neither team able to find the end zone. Both offenses had opportunities to take control, but timely fourth-down defensive stops kept the scoreboard at zero.
South Side reached the red zone twice, while Wantagh put together a lengthy drive late in the first quarter but also came away empty handed. The Warriors had another opportunity before halftime, but a failed fourth-down gadget play kept the game scoreless.
Wantagh came out of halftime with a different level of energy, using its defense and running game to take control.
Junior Luke Martini helped spark the turnaround with a sack on South Side's opening possession of the third quarter before making an impact offensively. Martini finished the Warriors' ensuing drive with 29 rushing yards and an 11-yard touchdown pass to junior Luke Rubbo on a trick play, giving Wantagh a 7-0 lead with 4:53 remaining in the third.
Martini continued to lead the way as the Warriors extended their advantage early in the fourth. After breaking off a 35-yard run, he capped the possession with a 3-yard touchdown run to make it 14-0.
“It was just a great team effort. South Side's a great team but we came in prepared. At the end of the day, our O-line came up big when we needed them. I'm proud of our team,” Martini said.
No. 2 South Side answered with its biggest offensive play of the evening when junior quarterback Rob Cesario Jr. connected with senior Ryan Solomon on a third-and-10. Solomon broke free for a touchdown, cutting the deficit to 14-7 with 10:48 remaining.
However, Wantagh quickly regained control with a nine play, 55-yard drive that ended with senior quarterback Max Avena sneaking into the end zone from a yard out.
South Side's comeback hopes were then ended by interceptions from senior Ray Azzariti and senior Joseph Adamo.
Martini finished with 130 rushing yards and a touchdown on 23 carries, while also throwing for 12 yards and a touchdown. Avena completed 11 of 16 passes for 124 yards and added a rushing score.
For South Side, the loss marked its third consecutive defeat in the county semifinals following its 2023 county championship campaign. Despite the disappointment, head coach Phil Onesto remained proud of his team's effort.
“It was two really good teams going against each other that gave everything they had and sometimes the ball doesn't bounce your way but I'm proud of my guys for the way they fought,” Onesto said.
Wantagh handed Plainedge its lone loss in the Sept. 10 opener, 36-33. There’s much more at stake in the rematch.
“We don't want this to end,” Sachs said. “We came into the playoffs wanting it to be a full month. We enjoy practice, we enjoy being together. It's going to be great. It's just going to be fun to prepare for another game.”