Garden City football’s state-record 68-game win streak may have ended a few months ago, but the Trojans continued another remarkable stretch Friday night that’s just as impressive.
Senior Anthony Asaro rushed for 167 yards and a pair of touchdowns and quarterback Brayden Robertiello threw for 147 yards and a score and rushed for 78 yards to lead top-seeded Garden City to a 31-21 victory over No. 2 Carey in the Nassau Conference II championship game at Hofstra for its 11th consecutive county title.
“Every championship is special in its own way,” Garden City head coach Dave Ettinger said. “These kids have worked extremely hard to get here and they knew it was going to take a big effort to win it. They executed pretty well on the biggest stage.”
The Trojans (10-1) will try to win their sixth straight Long Island championship when they take on Northport (10-1) in the Class II matchup Friday at Hofstra at noon. Carey finished 8-2 with both defeats coming to Garden City, including a 13-12 squeaker Oct. 17.
"I'm proud of our kids from start to finish," Carey head coach Mike Stanley said. "We had five season-ending injuries and our kids just kept fighting and found a way back to the county championship game. Unfortuantely for us, the better team won tonight. But that doesn't take away from how hard our kids prepared and fought."
Asaro missed the first meeting with a hamstring injury, but being a spectator when it mattered most wasn’t an option.
“I’m happy for Anthony because it’s been a tough season for him off and on with a couple of nagging injuries,” Ettinger said of Asaro, whose 5-yard touchdown run on the first play of the fourth quarter capped the team’s fourth straight scoring drive. “We held him out at some points during the year so he could be ready for this moment, and boy was he ready,” he added.
Asaro also had two sacks for a defense that did its best to contain Carey senior standout Justin DePietro, a Thorp Award candidate.
“Stopping DePietro doesn’t happen,” Ettinger said. “We just wanted to contain him. He had an explosive touchdown in the second quarter and that’s what he does. I thought we did a pretty good job overall. He’s a really talented kid.”
DePietro’s electric 28-yard touchdown run in the second quarter pulled Carey even after Asaro opened the scoring with a 6-yard score in the first. Garden City led 10-7 at halftime following a 21-yard field goal by Mark Escher, who hit a game-winning 25-yarder as time expired in the first meeting.
The Trojans then had a third quarter for the ages, racking up 207 yards. They opened the second half with a nifty play action that resulted in a 69-yard touchdown pass from Robertiello to Dylan Walsh to increase the lead to 17-7.
After the Seahawks responded with freshman signal-caller Gunnar Nelson’s 15-yard screen pass touchdown to David Avila to cut the margin back to a field goal, the Trojans countered and led 24-14 after a four-play, 83-yard drive highlighted by Robertiello’s 50-yard run and capped by Christian Roddini’s 3-yard touchdown.
Max Siragusa’s interception late in the third set up Garden City’s nine-play, 60-yard drive that concluded in the end zone courtesy of Asaro.
“No way I was missing this one,” Asaro said.